When Productivity Drops: What to Do When Your Heart’s Not in It
June 19, 2025
The Power Dilemma: Using Influence and Information with Integrity
July 3, 2025
When Productivity Drops: What to Do When Your Heart’s Not in It
The Hidden Barrier to Successful Promotions
Let’s get straight to it. Promoting someone based purely on performance doesn’t always work. I’ve seen it too many times in SMEs. Someone’s brilliant at their job, ticks all the boxes, and suddenly they’re handed a leadership role and it flops. Not because they lack skill, but because they’re carrying the silent killer: limitational thinking. It’s not a lack of ability, it’s a mindset issue. And if you don’t spot it early, it can do more damage than you think.
What is Limitational Thinking?
Limitational thinking is that inner voice that convinces someone they’re not capable of more. It sounds like:
“I’m not ready for that.”
“I don’t want to mess it up.”
“That’s not my job.”
It’s playing small, sticking to what’s safe, and assuming growth is for other people. Not what you want in a leader.
How It Shows Up at Work
Here’s the thing. It doesn’t always show up as fear or self-doubt. Sometimes it wears a disguise:
They’re always deferring decisions
They shy away from challenge or change
They’re brilliant operators but only within tight parameters
It’s not that they can’t lead. It’s that they don’t believe they can.
Why You Need to Spot It Before You Promote
Look, promoting the wrong person isn’t just a mistake. It can shake your team’s confidence, stall momentum, and create confusion. And in SMEs, we don’t have the luxury of waiting months to see if it’ll click.
Ask yourself:
Do they trust their instincts?
Are they comfortable in uncertainty?
Can they own decisions, even the messy ones?
Because leadership is about belief and resilience, not having all the answers.
Mindset Beats Skill Every Time
Skills can be trained. Systems can be learned. What you can’t teach overnight is self belief and growth mindset. If someone sees every challenge as a risk rather than an opportunity, they’ll freeze when it counts. And that ripples out across the team.
If I had to choose between someone technically average with a strong mindset or a top performer who doubts themselves, I know who I’m backing every time.
Build Belief Before the Promotion
Here’s the good news. You can develop people out of limitational thinking. But it takes intention.
- Give them space to lead in small, safe ways
- Let them fail and learn without punishment
- Share your own failures and how you bounced back
- Stretch their thinking, not just their to-do list
Don’t just prepare them to do more. Prepare them to believe they can.
Conclusion: Promote for Potential, Not Just Performance
Promotions should be earned but not just on results. Look beyond what someone does today and ask: can they stretch? Can they grow? Do they believe they belong at the table?
Because the best leaders aren’t always the loudest or most polished. They’re the ones who back themselves and their teams when it really counts.
Thinking About Promoting Someone Soon?
I help SME leaders make the right calls when it comes to people, culture and long term growth.
If you want straight talking advice on building a leadership team that actually leads book a free one hour call.
